Skip to content

Free shipping orders £40+ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4.8 / 5 with over 11,000 reviews

Special Makhani Cook-In Sauce

Sauce Shop

Unit price per 


No available purchase options for this selection.

Subscriptions can be amended or cancelled at any time, learn more 👈

Our rich and creamy North Indian style curry sauce, which lends itself to many dishes.

Methi (fenugreek leaves) adds a comforting fragrant note, Kashmiri chilli gives mild heat. Create traditional Butter Chicken, coat paneer before baking or frying or use as a base sauce for chickpea curry.

Forget everything you know about cooking sauces, your ticket to an easy meal is in this jar! Made the Sauce Shop way... in small batches, by hand, using nothing artificial.

  • Suitable for vegetarians
  • Heat level: mild
  • Serves 4
  • Nothing artificial, just full-on flavour
  • Made in the UK
Ingredients and Nutrition

Ingredients: Tomato Puree (50%), Butter (Cow’s Milk) (10%), Cream (Cow’s Milk) (5%), Sugar, Garlic, Ginger, White Grape Vinegar, Salt, Garam Masala, Fenugreek Leaves, Paprika, Smoked Paprika, Cardamom, Kashmiri Chilli Powder, Bay Leaves (see allergens in bold).

Nutrition per 100g: Energy 161kcal / 671kJ, Fat 9.2g (of which saturates 5.7g), Carbohydrate 16.8g (of which sugars 12.0g), Protein 2.7g, Salt 1.21g.

Storage information

Best before at least 12 months from delivery, once opened keep refrigerated and use in 3 days.


2021: 1-star Great Taste Award

As seen on social 

📷: ricohydeyhi

In 2014 we came to the realisation that the sauces we were buying weren't doing our food justice. What started in a home kitchen, is now a team of 34 food lovers producing thousands of bottles of sauce on a weekly basis.

Pam & James


The most rock 'n' roll hot sauce ever made has landed. A Sauce Shop X Foals collaboration.

Shop now

Customer Reviews

Based on 82 reviews
Jessica Jenkins (Hengoed, GB)
Gorgeous sauce!

Really tasty sauce - doesn’t taste artificial like some jar sauces and it was full of flavour. Will definitely be buying more of this one!

Nothing artificial in anything we do. We pride ourselves on that! :D Great to hear you enjoyed. Thank you!

Yvonne Warren (Derby, GB)
My favourite sauce for chicken

So pleased I found this sauce on your website, it's very tasty on chicken. I hope it's always available to buy, as this is a definite regular goto in my cupboard.

No intention of getting rid of this goodness!

Andrew H. (Broom, GB)
Good Home-style Sauce

I've spent plenty of hours cooking down masala sauces from scratch and this has the texture and flavour of a good slow and low home-style masala. Overriding flavour is deep tomato and fenugreek. Saw someone say it was bitter - I didn't get that at all - although, I'm used to cooking with all kinds of tomato varieties and low sugar and salt. If you don't like fenugreek, maybe not for you, but I liked it very much and you could certainly play around with additional spices, butter and cream. Best alternative to a good homemade sauce I've tried.

Thanks a lot Andrew. Pleased to hear you're enjoying the product! Watch this space for new flavours soon

matthew wilkinson (Ellesmere Port, GB)
Makhani sauce

I have been cooking curry dishes from scratch for years now, there are so many different methods of preparing and cooking with the wide range of ingredients available. I would never normally use jars of curry sauce, the type ready available in all supermarkets. I tried this sauce as I have bought a variety of items from The Sauce Shop and it is truly amazing as an alternative in a recipe to tinned tomatoes or passata. Super with beef chicken and lamb. Would highly recommend.

Hey Matthew,

Definitely! We wanted Cook-In sauces to be quick and easy for customers who want to whip something up fast but still with great quality of ingredients so food is still super tasty. Great to hear that appears to come across in your meals with the products! Thank so much for giving them a try and enjoying our products :)

J. Ryan Stinnett (Southwark, GB)
The best!

This is our favourite cook-in sauce, highly recommended! It tastes great with many different veggie combinations.

Love it, thanks!

Doreen Shaw (Bolton, GB)

I was really looking forward to this sauce but found it quite bitter and would not purchase again.

Hey Doreen,

I'm going to drop you an email! This doesn't sound quite right at all and it could be a bad batch. We definitely don't want you to be left disappointed! As this product is normally well liked. Lets get this rectified!

Anthony Collins (Poplar, GB)

Very rich and flavoursome.

Jeannie Williams (Filey, GB)
For fast food - in a good way.

These are ideal for a quick and easy meal, especially when fresh veggies are regularly coming out of people's gardens and allotments. Different flavours would be welcome. Add chilli for a hotter experience. Definitely recommended. The only cook-in sauce I would ever buy.

Yessss thanks Jeannie! Have you tried the Ranchero or Mother Tomato, they're the other flavours we offer at the moment but we'll definitely be expanding the range further soon!

Tony J (Stromness, GB)
An excellent flavoursome sauce

Used this as the base for a lamb meatball curry - the combination was exceptionally good. A great sauce base for when you want a quick and tasty curry.

We love it, lamb meatball curry sounds like a great use for it!

Sylvia Hunter. (Ilkley, GB)
Great flavour

Have made lamb curry with this sauce also chicken curry .this will be a regular for us

Close (esc)


Use this popup to embed a mailing list sign up form. Alternatively use it as a simple call to action with a link to a product or a page.

Age verification

By clicking enter you are verifying that you are old enough to consume alcohol.



Added to basket